Is it permissible to help a playing partner line up putts while playing a better-ball tournament? Rules Guy has the answer

What do the rules say about assisting a partner during a team match?

Getty Images

The Rules of Golf are tricky! Thankfully, we’ve got the guru. Our Rules Guy knows the book front to back. Got a question? He’s got all the answers.

What do the rules say about assisting a partner during a team match?

Our member-member tournament is a partners’ better ball. Apparently, one team had a player lining up the ball on her partner’s putts. What?! Is that really legal? —Shay Ballard, Prescott, Ariz.

Shay, you’ll forgive Rules Guy for his perplexity at your distress. Partners are… partners. They’re supposed to work together. Thus, unsurprisingly, this maneuver is absolutely permitted.

Under Rule 23.5, in partner forms of play, the partner may take any action with the player’s ball that the player is allowed to do. This includes replacing the ball and, so long as the ball is marked at the time, rotating it so that it is aligned as desired on the putting green. Yes!

For more partner-related guidance from our guru, read on …

Player 1 marks Player 2’s ball on the green and moves the ball to another place on the green without advising Player 2 what he has done. Player 2 then unwittingly putts from the wrong spot. What, if any, penalties apply? This situation occurred to me not long ago, and our pro advised that Player 1 should incur a two-shot penalty but on second thought wasn’t too sure. —David Lauer, via email

Rules Guy bunker

We will assume this occurred in stroke play. First, a caveat: the ruling would be the same if Player 1 had simply moved the ball (crazy, but it happens) instead of marking, lifting and tossing the ball aside, although it changes how the ruling comes about. But we digress.

In stroke play, Player 1 is an outside influence in this scenario, and there was no penalty for moving the ball even though they were not allowed to do so under the Rules.

Since Player 2 was unaware that the ball was in a wrong place (or, if marked and lifted, taken out of play), said player isn’t penalized and must continue on with the ball played from the wrong-but-now-right place.

Related articles

Shocking lip-out costs Women’s Open contender a boatload of money

Shocking lip-out costs Women’s Open contender a boatload of money Lilia Vu lips out a par putt on 18 to fall into a four-way tie for second…

‘I messed up’: Nelly Korda’s brutal finish costs her Women’s Open title shot at St. Andrews

‘I messed up’: Nelly Korda’s brutal finish costs her Women’s Open title shot at St. Andrews Nelly Korda covers face following her final-round 72 at the 2024…

Keegan Bradley wins BMW Championship, first title since captaincy nod

Keegan Bradley wins BMW Championship, first title since captaincy nod Keegan Bradley celebrates winning the BMW Championship. Keegan Bradley’s 7th PGA Tour win came at a crucial…

Rory McIlroy snaps driver, then nearly pulls off the unthinkable

Rory McIlroy snaps driver, then nearly pulls off the unthinkable Rory McIlroy snaps his driver then plays a shot from the water at the BMW Championship. Rory…

2024 BMW Championship money: Here’s how much every player made

2024 BMW Championship money: Here’s how much every player made Adam Scott tees off on the 9th hole during the final round of the BMW Championship on…

“This is outrageous…absolute disgrace” – Matt Fitzpatrick & Scottie Scheffler lash out at PGA rules official at the BMW Championship

“This is outrageous…absolute disgrace” – Matt Fitzpatrick & Scottie Scheffler lash out at PGA rules official at the BMW Championship BMW Championship – Final Round – Source:…